Thursday, 8 March 2007

Or else ... like do something tough

Some may be stuck in the embarrassing language of New Age pap, but not so the literary giants at DailyKos who can dish out such sophisticated bromides as "[the troops are] in harm's way" in a peice that threatens dire consequences for the Democrats if they do not get us out of Iraq (AlterNet: War on Iraq: Democrats: Work to Get Us Out of Iraq ... or Else!):
We do not know what the next year will bring, but we know how to start getting where we know the endgame of Iraq will eventually go, and the most essential task we currently have to to ensure that no more lives than necessary go towards the political cowardice of the current institutionalized quagmire.
Now that's the sort of sentence (perhaps along with "weapons of mass destruction-related program activities") that probably gives his colleague MissLaura a hard-on. But this is not just about impressive rhetoric; there is a deadline attached to the threat:
There are no more acceptable six month windows to see if the same "plan", called a different name, will produce different results.
Impressive, especially in light of the approval elsewhere in the "netroots" of the latest Democratic proposal on Iraq, this one calling for some sort of withdrawal in 2008 (yes that's an at the end of those digits). Fortunately there is raw fury elsewhere:
You have no idea how much raw fury there is out there, just under the surface. And all the "Democratic apologists" like me are on our very last ounce of patience, and all the grassroots supporters have torches lit and and at the ready, and all the Democrats and Republicans in your district are watching to see whether you're really different from the Republicans or not...
You mean... no... you couldn't... you mean, like Nader said?



Marginal hate

It's good news all around on the "netroots" front! Referring to recent polls, Chris Bowers writes (MyDD :: Two New National Polls):

[I]t is heartening to see that nearly half of all respondents refused to refuse to support any of the candidates during the primary season. And what's up with the marginal candidates having so many haters?
Why the puzzlement? Why not celebrate both effects as victories for the "netroots"? On the one hand, 50% support for anyone (which is a pack led by the likes of Clinton and Obama) endorses the

"[almost] any Democrat will do" gradualism. At the same time, the effort to marginalize and denigrate principled candidates ("trophy candidate", "height becomes relevant", "New Age pap") can be claimed to be yielding payoffs based on the second finding (haters for marginal candidates). This is no time to rest on laurels -- work remains for only 11% of respondents hate Kucinich, as opposed to 100% of the "netroots"! The people, as is their ignorant wont, trail the leaders significantly.



Tuesday, 6 March 2007

Progressive propaganda machine

Sometimes progressives say the darndest things! DarkSyde laments the power of the right-wing propaganda machine (Daily Kos: Chuckle With Charley) but ends on the positive note that we might be able to use our correspondence to reality to build our own propaganda:

The reason right-wing propaganda is so effective is because they've built up an interlocking network of think-tanks, media venues, and grassroots political organizations -- some of the latter in the guise of legitimate, mainstream churches. The think-tanks take ideas that would normally be considered revolting if presented in the nude (Take from the poorest and give to the richest) and craft it into appealing, clever sounding deceptions (It will stimulate the economy and help the poor!). Right-wing media spreads the deception, nurtures racism, and demonizes opposition (Liberals want to give your tax dollars to welfare queens!). Wingnut clerics dress it up in pleasant sounding bits of religious doctrine and beat it mercilessly into the heads of their congregations week after week. It’s a seamless, well-oiled, machine.



But there's a chance progressives can build something similar, and we do enjoy one advantage: We don't have to create and constantly reinforce a high-maintenance pseudo-reality that ends up killing people or ruining lives.
Judging by the demonizing of the opposition (and by opposition I obviously mean the leftist types like Nader and Kucinich, who are after all far more reality based) that is already underway in the progressive blogs, this is a project slated for success.



Monday, 5 March 2007

Obama's heavy stones

As everyone aspiring to high elected office has to, Obama went to AIPAC to kiss some ass, but fortunately TPM and MyDD see his performance as not bad at all (Text of the Obama Speech at AIPAC today | TPMCafe). The speech continues the usual meaningless rhetoric that is Obama's signature:
It won't be easy. Some of those stones will be heavy and tough for the United States to carry. Others with be heavy and tough for Israel to carry. And even more will be difficult for the world. But together, we will begin again.
The only thing I can think of doing "together" with Obama is not having a "conversation" with Hillary. But if Obama decided to leave his stones at AIPAC, he sure was right that they are some heavy ones. Here are some of the top hits:
But I am also fortunate to have seen Israel from the air.

On my journey that January day, I flew on an IDF helicopter to the border zone. The helicopter took us over the most troubled and dangerous areas and that narrow strip between the West Bank and the Mediterranean Sea. At that height, I could see the hills and the terrain that generations have walked across. I could truly see how close everything is and why peace through security is the only way for Israel.

Our helicopter landed in the town of Kiryat Shmona on the border. What struck me first about the village was how familiar it looked. The houses and streets looked like ones you might find in a suburb in America. I could imagine young children riding their bikes down the streets. I could imagine the sounds of their joyful play just like my own daughters. There were cars in the driveway. The shrubs were trimmed. The families were living their lives.

Then, I saw a house that had been hit with one of Hezbollah's Katyusha rockets.

I suspect that I have quoted too much and risked losing you as you collapse in a mixture of laughter and tears of incredulity. Perhaps you are wondering if Obama got to see some of the Palestinians in refugee camps and in the bantustans that Israel has created. Or you may be curious as to whether Obama managed to score any civilian hits -- he was in an IDF helicopter after all. Maybe the IDF helicopter even strayed into Lebanese territory, as the Israelis accidentally do every now and then, giving Old Stones Obama a look at the territory from where the dastardly Katyusha rockets were launched. In passing I will also note our silver tongued wunderkind's turn of phrase in aid of upturning the truth: "peace through security" is his prescription to complement Israel's unwillingness to achieve it's much desired security, through peace. Do not let your mind wander far though, for there is more:

It is important to remember this history—that Israel had unilaterally withdrawn from Lebanon only to have Iran supply Hezbollah with thousands of rockets.

Ah yes, history lessons. Obama's hyper-religiousness (I presume), which usually includes magical beliefs about the origin of things, permits him to visualise an arbitrary starting point for history: the withdrawal of Israel from Lebanon. That Israel "withdrew" might clue a less self-certain person to what Israel did to require its withdrawal, but such mere facts are no match for the verbal footwork of Obama's "unilateral withdrawal". The facts of the recent Israeli terrorist strikes against Lebanon, killing and displacing thousands of civilians, before it had to once again "withdraw" its laughably vaunted troops -- those facts too might give pause to those lacking the heavy stones. Obama, made of sterner stuff, marches on:

That effort begins with a clear and strong commitment to the security of Israel: our strongest ally in the region and its only established democracy.

It is fortunate for Obama that his history starts with Israel's "withdrawal" from Lebanon, for that absolves him of pondering about democracies in the region, such as the elected government of Mossadegh in Iran, which we toppled.

Perhaps the best measure of progress (for progressives) is how we treat (or let others in power treat) the most disadvantaged members of the human population -- such as the Palestinians. By that measure, support of individuals like Obama is one of the most regressive acts we can indulge in.

Saturday, 3 March 2007

The appropriate use of "faggot"

From the "he didn't just put it that way, did he?" department we have Matt Stoller (MyDD :: Direct Democracy for People-Powered Politics) outraged by Coulter referring to Edwards as a "faggot". The thing that seems to bother Stoller is that Coulter called Edwards a "faggot":

Anyway, one thing to keep in mind, aside from the conservative uncoolness, is that she called a major Democratic candidate a faggot. Ok, she's an entertainer, so whatever. But keep in mind that prior to her appearance, most major Republican Presidential candidates appeared on the stage to make appeals to the audience. I wonder if they support Coulter's statement. Do they think it's appropriate to call John Edwards a faggot?
Well, this raises the question of whether Stoller thinks it is appropriate to call anyone (including a gay person) a faggot? Whether the person is a major Democratic candidate is irrelevant. The issue here is not what Edwards was called, but that someone used the term "faggot". Surely Stoller can see that?



Friday, 2 March 2007

The irresponsibility of people

As he unleashed dictatorial terror in Chile, Kissinger remarked that he didn't see why "we should have to stand by and let a country go Communist due to the irresponsibility of its own people". Kissinger was no liberal, but it is not difficult to find eager proponents among liberals of the idea of limiting the options available to the people, as evidenced by the character assassination of Dennis Kucinich by elements of the "netroots" (see entries in this blog for examples). Speaking about a Marine pilot who wrote with perverse glee at the killing of civilians in Iraq, Matt Taibbi (AlterNet: Why Can't We Talk about Peace in Public?) writes:
I believe that Marine pilot is driven by the same forces that render the presidential candidacy of someone like Dennis Kucinich impossible in America. A country that feeds itself through the manufacture of war technology is bound to view peace, nonviolence and mercy as seditious concepts. It will create policies first and then people to fit its machines, finding wars to fight and creating killers to fight them. If that's true of us, and I think it is, our troubles won't be over even if someone brings the Iraq war to an end. We'll be treating the symptom and not the disease. And the reason our elections are a sham is that the disease is never on the table. Excepting the occasional Kucinich, no one in either party is interested in trying to change who we are, no matter how sick we become.
The "new progressives" may not find Kucinich's ideas of peace seditious, but they are on record with the more amusing claim that these ideas are "New Age pap". The Iraq war and winning elections, and setting the right "frame" in pursuit of these goals, are the limits of this new pragmatism, and what is good for the goose should suffice for the people.


Thursday, 1 March 2007

Center of left

The term "progressive", it appears, commits one to a constant fear of the past. In particular one's forerunners: patricide is the easy path to the throne! Matt Stoller, worried about the "netroots" report card from the CBC (MyDD :: Fox News and the CBC) reacts with the tried and tested "It wasn't us! It was the old progressives!":

[P]eople like Amy Sullivan talk about the religious left and the need to reach out to 'values voters' as if black churches have not been an important backbone of progressive politics for fifty years. The CBC doesn't recognize that the netroots are not actually the old progressive movement. We are new, and much more open to collaboration and working together with a newly energized African-American political progressive movement.

The indignation is premature. Indeed black churches have been an important backbone of progressive politics. And it has not only historically collaborated with liberal elements (such as in the Northeast) -- including our current favourite nemesis Joe Leiberman -- but also reached across history (and geography) to tap into and draw inspiration from the deep humanism of other leftists/progressives (one example is Martin Luther King's encounter with the thoughts and legacy of Gandhi, who in turn applied some of the ideas of Thoreau). There is a strong and continuous thread running through the history of humanist leftism, arguably the only one that has produced sustainable results.



The "old progressives" were neither ignorant nor uninterested in this history and this association. To the contrary, it is that shared humanism that enabled the collaboration between them. It is (or should be) hence unsurprising that an "End of History" attitude arouses suspicion, especially when accompanied by intolerance and disrespect.

Meanwhile, I hope that progressive African-American leaders begin to recognize that the progressive white world is not monolithic, and that there are real allies here who are trying to figure out a way to deal in good faith with those with whom our interests are aligned.

Alignment of interests serves short-term interests (and there is nothing necessarily wrong with that). Left movements are built on alignment of principles. And in that sense, the "progressive white world", monolithic or not, may become irrelevant in the future to the progressive world, judging by growing leftist groundswell in the so-called "third world".



The difference between the "old progressives" and the new "netroots" is spelled out wittily by Bitch|Lab (Flicked Off) who quotes Alternet / In These Times:

Yet when it comes to issues of diversity, A-list bloggers like Moulitsas and Stoller can get defensive, and at times, dismissive. “Take a look at what you have today. Take a look at the folks who’re leading the party, dominating the media, or even within corporations. Do you think the top ranks of any of those institutions is any more representative?” responds Stoller, his voice rising in indignation.



[...]



In his [Markos Moulitsas] view, it’s simply absurd to demand what he sarcastically describes as an “affirmative action of ideas” within an inherently meritocratic medium such as the blogosphere: “I don’t see how you can say, ‘Well, let’s give more voice to African American lesbians.’



[...]



As for the relative paucity of top female progressive bloggers, Moulitsas is indifferent: “I haven’t given it a lot of thought. I find it totally uninteresting. What I’m interested in is winning elections, and I don’t give a shit what you look like.”

And Bitch comments:

Of course, but shouldn’t Kos care about that and wonder why? It seems to me to be at the heart of what a more progressive vision of the Democratic party was supposed to be all about. Yes? The paucity may not have to do with lack of talent, as Kos implies, but lack of interest in what women are writing about. Why should women support people who find what we have to say “uninteresting” and not meriting your concern?



[...]



[A] hiearchical system has been forged with Technorati rankings and Blogad networks where members have the right to deny membership. And it comes complete with justifications about natural deservingness that ring hollow to anyone familiar with the vicissitudes of oppression and injustice.

But those aren’t really things people who “just want to win elections” care about. Afterall, elections are very much about accepting procedural justice and equality of opportunity as the sine qua non of politics. It’s a passive politics, an episodic politics. It’s the kind of politics enthusiasts pushing for a more substantive politics rejected as alienating and unresponsive to the desire of people to actively participate in the decision-making processes that affected their lives.

As long as we don’t question the eternal naturalness of a procedurlistic, episodic politics, and forge something new, then there will never be democratic participation, just endless reinstantiations of new hierarchical social relations, new hegemonies which justify the everlasting natural order of it all.